Can Criminal Charges Be Dropped in Ontario?
Home >> Blogs >>Can Criminal Charges Be Dropped in Ontario?
Can Criminal Charges Be Dropped in Ontario? Withdrawals, Diversion & Can the Victim Drop Charges?
She doesn’t want to press charges anymore. Can she just drop them?” It is one of the most common questions a criminal defence lawyer hears, and the answer surprises most people.
In Ontario, charges can absolutely end without a trial. But the person who decides is not the complainant, and not the police. This guide explains who has the power to drop charges, the different ways a case can end early, and what a Toronto criminal defence lawyer does to get there.
In Ontario, a victim cannot drop criminal charges. Once police lay a charge, only the Crown prosecutor can withdraw or stay it. Charges are commonly withdrawn when there is no reasonable prospect of conviction, when it is not in the public interest to continue, after diversion, in exchange for a peace bond, or when the case is stayed for unreasonable delay.
Can the Victim Drop Charges in Ontario?
No. In Canada, criminal charges are brought by the state, not by the person who made the complaint. Once police lay a charge, the case belongs to the Crown prosecutor.
The complainant’s wishes still matter. Crown attorneys consider them, and an unwilling witness can weaken the case. But a complainant who “drops the charges” is really asking the Crown to withdraw them, and the Crown can say no.
Who Decides Whether Charges Are Dropped
The Crown prosecutor decides. Ontario Crowns review every charge against two questions:
- Is there a reasonable prospect of conviction? If the evidence is too weak, the charge should not continue.
- Is it in the public interest to prosecute? Factors include the seriousness of the offence, the accused’s record, and the impact on the victim and community.
If either answer becomes “no” at any point, the Crown should withdraw the charge. A defence lawyer’s job is often to show the Crown why that point has been reached.
Withdrawn, Stayed, Acquitted or Discharged: What Is the Difference?
These outcomes sound similar, but they have very different effects on your record and future.
Outcome | Who decides | What it means | Criminal record? |
|---|---|---|---|
Withdrawal | Crown | The charge is ended before trial. | No conviction. Police records may remain until destruction is requested. |
Stay of proceedings | Crown or judge | The case is paused. A Crown stay can be restarted within one year; a judicial stay is usually final. | No conviction. |
Acquittal | Judge or jury | You are found not guilty at trial. | No conviction. |
Absolute or conditional discharge | Judge | You are found guilty, but no conviction is registered. | Record is kept for 1 year (absolute) or 3 years (conditional), then removed from CPIC. |
A withdrawn charge does not automatically wipe police files such as fingerprints and photos. You can usually apply to have them destroyed. If you were convicted in the past, see our guide to record suspensions in Canada.
Ways Charges Get Withdrawn in Ontario
1. Weak or unreliable evidence
After receiving disclosure, a lawyer reviews police notes, video, statements and witness accounts. Gaps, contradictions and Charter breaches are put to the Crown in writing. Many charges are withdrawn at this stage.
2. Diversion programs
Diversion lets eligible people, usually first-time accused facing minor charges, complete a task instead of going through a prosecution. Ontario’s Direct Accountability Program can require community service, a donation, counselling or restitution. When it is completed, the charge is withdrawn.
Diversion is common for minor theft, mischief and some low-level drug or assault charges. Read more about theft charges in Ontario.
3. Peace bond
In some cases, the Crown withdraws the criminal charge if the accused agrees to a peace bond, a court order to keep the peace for up to 12 months. A peace bond is not a conviction. We explain it fully in our peace bond guide.
4. Charter violations
If police searched illegally, denied your right to a lawyer or detained you without grounds, key evidence may be excluded. Without that evidence, the Crown may have no case left.
5. Unreasonable delay (the Jordan ceiling)
In R. v. Jordan (2016), the Supreme Court of Canada set firm time limits. Cases in the Ontario Court of Justice must finish within 18 months of the charge, and cases in the Superior Court within 30 months. Delay caused by the defence does not count. If the limit is passed, the charges are usually stayed.
Domestic Assault Charges: Why Withdrawal Is Harder
Domestic or intimate partner violence cases follow special policies in Ontario. Police are directed to lay charges where there are reasonable grounds, and Crowns do not withdraw charges just because the complainant asks.
Common realities in Toronto domestic cases:
- No-contact conditions often stop the accused returning home or speaking to their partner. Only the court can change them, not the complainant.
- A recanting witness can still be compelled to testify. Their earlier statement to police may be used as evidence in some situations.
- Early resolution options can include a peace bond, counselling through the Partner Assault Response (PAR) program, or a conditional discharge.
If the complainant wants conditions changed, they should speak to the Crown or the Victim/Witness Assistance Program. They should not contact the accused or the defence directly to arrange it. See how an assault lawyer in Toronto handles these cases.
How a Defence Lawyer Gets Charges Dropped
Charges are rarely withdrawn by chance. They are usually withdrawn because someone built the case for it.
- Reviews full disclosure and identifies weaknesses early
- Writes to the Crown setting out legal and factual problems
- Gathers mitigating material, such as character letters, counselling records or proof of employment
- Pushes for diversion where the client is eligible
- Tracks delay and brings a Jordan application where justified
- Brings Charter motions to exclude illegally obtained evidence
If the Crown will not withdraw, your lawyer can still negotiate a reduced charge or a resolution that avoids a criminal record. Our article on how lawyers advise on guilty pleas explains that decision.
Common Mistakes That Hurt Your Case
Many strong defences are damaged in the first few hours. Avoid these:
- Explaining “your side of the story” to police
- Posting about the arrest on social media
- Contacting the complainant, even to apologise
- Missing your first court date
- Waiting weeks before hiring a lawyer
If you were charged with assault, our guide on what happens after an assault charge in Ontario walks through the next stages.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a victim refuse to testify in Ontario?
A complainant can be served with a subpoena and legally required to attend court. Refusing to attend or testify can lead to a warrant or contempt. In practice, a reluctant witness often affects how the Crown proceeds.
How long does it take for charges to be withdrawn?
It varies. Some charges are withdrawn within weeks after disclosure review or diversion. Others take months of negotiation. Most Ontario Court of Justice cases must finish within 18 months under the Jordan framework.
Does a withdrawn charge show up on a background check?
A withdrawn charge is not a conviction and does not appear as one. However, police records of the charge may appear on some vulnerable sector checks. You can usually ask police to destroy fingerprints and photos after withdrawal.
Can I get charges dropped without a lawyer?
It is possible, but rare. Crowns respond to specific legal and factual arguments, not general requests. A lawyer knows what to put in front of the Crown and when.
Is diversion available for domestic assault?
General diversion is usually not available for domestic charges. However, some cases resolve through the PAR program, a peace bond or a conditional discharge, depending on the facts and the accused’s history.
Talk to a Criminal Lawyer in Toronto
The earlier a lawyer is involved, the more options you have to get charges withdrawn. Waiting can mean missed diversion deadlines and lost evidence.
Nimrata Sandhu is a criminal lawyer in Toronto who works to have charges withdrawn, stayed or resolved without a criminal record. Call (416) 380-4154 or book a confidential consultation.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different. Speak to a lawyer about your situation.